帶入肉體:在死刑陰影下的人格
作者:梁家恩(淡江大學全球政治經濟學系副教授)
摘要:
在本文中,我將懲罰視為一個強大的社會制度,旨在維護國家或社會所定義的價值觀。在某些國家,死刑作為一種懲罰可視為是對犯罪個體或不受社會歡迎個體的最強大武器。然而,本文認為所有個體都具有豐富的背景故事,超越了簡單的死刑犯身分。因此,本文指出有必要用「人性化」的角度看待那些在死刑囚室中的人並凸顯對他們人格的肯認。本文討論所依據的資料有二,包括和專門替死刑犯拍攝影像的攝影師所進行的訪談,以及和強調應運用「生物心理社會」途徑的非政府組織的訪談。根據前述資料的討論,促使我們能更深思熟慮去思考死刑的成效,以及不斷使用死刑是否顯示國家和社會未能保護最弱勢的人。
Bringing in the Body: Personhood in the Shadow of the Death Penalty
Author:Kar Yen Leong (Associate Professor, Tamkang University)
Abstract:
In certain countries, the death penalty is used to punish individual criminals or those society deems to be undesirable. However, I state all individuals are ‘storied’ carrying with them complex narratives which go beyond simple labels. Thus, I state in this paper that there is a need to ‘humanise’ those on death row and to bring to light an acknowledgement of their personhood. I rely on an interview conducted with a photographer who specialises in images of death-row inmates as well as research from an organisation which emphasises on the need for a ‘biopsychosocial’ approach. Doing so allows us to ponder deeper questions as to the efficacy of capital punishment and whether its constant use is an indication of the failure of the state and of society to protect its most vulnerable members.
Keywords
death penalty, photography, biopsychosocial, materiality, punishment, power, narrative, narratives
全文下載